Reading List

Authors Like Agatha Christie

Agatha Christie was born in Torquay in 1890, and during the First World War she worked in the dispensary of the town's Red Cross Hospital, which is where her lifelong interest in poisons began. In the quiet hours there she plotted a detective story; a group of Belgian refugees living in a Torquay parish gave her the idea of making her detective a retired Belgian policeman. She finished The Mysterious Affair at Styles around 1916 and it was published in 1920, with Hercule Poirot in his first case. Sixty-six detective novels and fourteen story collections followed, along with The Mousetrap, which opened in the West End in 1952, and her books are reported to have sold more than two billion copies. What readers come to her for is a particular contract: a closed circle of suspects, every clue placed in plain sight, and a solution that rearranges everything you thought you knew about everyone in the room. The writers below either built that contract with her in the Golden Age, inherited it, or took it apart to see what it could hold.

By Lisanne Swart · 10 authors · Golden Age mystery · The modern whodunit · Updated October 2026


Quick answer

If you love Agatha Christie, start with Dorothy L. Sayers, her contemporary and fellow founder of the Detection Club. For the other Golden Age Queens of Crime, read Ngaio Marsh and Margery Allingham. For the puzzle written now, Richard Osman and Anthony Horowitz. And for the closest thing to And Then There Were None written by anyone else, Yukito Ayatsuji.

10 authors like Agatha Christie

01
Her contemporary · Closest match

Dorothy L. Sayers

British · b. 1893 · Crime novelist

Sayers introduced the aristocratic amateur detective Lord Peter Wimsey in Whose Body? (1923) and the crime novelist Harriet Vane in Strong Poison (1930), in which Wimsey has weeks to save her from the gallows. She was among the first women to be granted an Oxford degree, in 1920, worked as an advertising copywriter at S. H. Benson until 1929 (the setting of Murder Must Advertise, 1933), and was a founder member of the Detection Club in 1930 alongside Christie. She later translated Dante.

The obvious next step, and a different temperament. Sayers plays the same fair-play game as Christie, but she lets the novel around the puzzle grow: Gaudy Night is as much about women, work and intellectual life in Oxford as about who is writing the poison-pen letters. Where Christie keeps character as lean as the plot needs, Sayers gives it room, and the Wimsey–Vane books are the place to see it.

— Lisanne

Every book by Dorothy L. Sayers →

02
Golden Age, from the theatre

Ngaio Marsh

New Zealander · b. 1895 · Crime novelist

Marsh wrote 32 detective novels featuring Roderick Alleyn of Scotland Yard, beginning with A Man Lay Dead (1934). She was also a theatre director in Christchurch, staging Shakespeare with the Canterbury University College Drama Society from 1942, and several of her mysteries are set among actors, including Enter a Murderer (1935), Opening Night (1951) and her last, Light Thickens (1982). She was made a Dame in 1966 and named a Grand Master by the Mystery Writers of America in 1978.

The Queen of Crime with a director's eye. Marsh stages her murders like scenes, controlling entrances, sight-lines and exactly what the audience notices, which is Christie's sleight of hand done with stage machinery. Her theatre novels are the place to start; the country-house books are closer to Christie but less her own.

— Lisanne

Every book by Ngaio Marsh →

03
The strangest Queen of Crime

Margery Allingham

British · b. 1904 · Crime novelist

Allingham's detective Albert Campion first appeared as a minor character in The Crime at Black Dudley (1929), and early readers took him for a parody of Sayers's Lord Peter Wimsey; he went on to 18 novels as a vague-seeming upper-class man working under an assumed name. Her husband, Philip Youngman Carter, helped plot the interwar books and finished her last one after her death in 1966. The Tiger in the Smoke, set in a fog-bound London, is often counted her best novel.

Christie's tradition pushed somewhere moodier. The early Campion books are light adventure; the later ones, above all The Tiger in the Smoke, are closer to a thriller with a real sense of evil in them, a register Christie rarely reached for. Read her when St Mary Mead starts to feel too tidy.

— Lisanne

Every book by Margery Allingham →

04
Where the form came from

Arthur Conan Doyle

Scottish · b. 1859 · Novelist

Doyle introduced Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson in A Study in Scarlet (1887), and the short stories that followed in The Strand Magazine fixed the shape of the detective story for the next century: the brilliant observer, the admiring friend who narrates, and the reader invited to keep up. Christie read the early Holmes stories with her sister Madge, who later challenged her to write a detective story of her own.

The ancestor rather than a match. Poirot's first case is narrated by Captain Hastings in a role Watson made famous, and Christie's habit of explaining everything in a final gathering owes a lot to Holmes's closing explanations. What Doyle does not do is play fair in her sense: Holmes often knows things the reader was never shown, and seeing that difference makes clear what Christie added.

— Lisanne

Every book by Arthur Conan Doyle →

05
The puzzle with an inner life

P.D. James

British · b. 1920 · Crime novelist

James introduced Adam Dalgliesh, a Scotland Yard commander who is also a published poet, in Cover Her Face (1962), and wrote the books while working for a London hospital board and then the Home Office. Shroud for a Nightingale, set in a nurses' training school, won the CWA Silver Dagger. She was made a life peer in 1991, received the CWA Diamond Dagger in 1987, and wrote a short history of the genre, Talking About Detective Fiction (2009).

The same closed-community structure as Christie — a hospital, a nursing school, a publishing house — but with every suspect given a full interior life, victims included. James's prose is slower and denser, and the murders cost more. If Christie's characters ever felt like pieces on a board, this is the answer.

— Lisanne

Every book by P.D. James →

06
The psychological turn

Ruth Rendell

British · b. 1930 · Crime novelist

Rendell wrote the Inspector Wexford series from From Doon with Death (1964) onwards, and a long run of standalone psychological crime novels, some under the name Barbara Vine; the first Vine novel, A Dark-Adapted Eye, won the Edgar Award in 1987. A Judgement in Stone opens by telling you the murderer and the motive: “Eunice Parchman killed the Coverdale family because she could not read or write.” She was made a life peer in 1997 and openly disliked Christie's books.

The furthest departure from Christie on this list, and worth it for the distance. Christie's psychology serves the puzzle; Rendell's puzzle serves the psychology, and she is far more interested in how an ordinary person arrives at a killing than in who did it. Reading her shows how much Christie deliberately left out.

— Lisanne

Every book by Ruth Rendell →

07
Closest modern match

Richard Osman

British · b. 1970 · Crime novelist

Osman, the co-creator and long-time co-presenter of the BBC quiz show Pointless, published The Thursday Murder Club in 2020: four residents of the Coopers Chase retirement village in Kent, one of them a former spy, investigate murders the police would rather they left alone. It was the UK's number-one Christmas bestseller, a first for a debut novelist, and the series reached its fifth book, The Impossible Fortune, in 2025. A Netflix film followed in August 2025.

The nearest thing to Miss Marple's village written now: a community that underestimates its oldest members, a large cast, and properly fair clues under a warm and very funny surface. Osman is gentler and more sentimental than Christie, but the appeal is the same one — murder made sociable.

— Lisanne

Every book by Richard Osman →

08
The homage that takes it apart

Anthony Horowitz

British · b. 1955 · Novelist

Horowitz wrote scripts for ITV's Agatha Christie's Poirot, created Foyle's War and wrote for Midsomer Murders. Magpie Murders contains a complete 1950s village mystery featuring the detective Atticus Pünd, wrapped inside a contemporary story about the editor who discovers its final chapter is missing; Moonflower Murders and Marble Hall Murders (2025) repeat the trick. He has also written Sherlock Holmes and James Bond novels for those authors' estates.

Where Osman channels Christie's spirit, Horowitz rebuilds her machinery and then comments on it from outside. The novel-within-the-novel in Magpie Murders is a precise pastiche of a late Christie, and the frame around it is about why readers want that kind of book at all. The best choice for anyone curious about how a fair-play mystery is made.

— Lisanne

Every book by Anthony Horowitz →

09
The village mystery, across the Atlantic

Louise Penny

Canadian · b. 1958 · Crime novelist

Penny worked for about eighteen years as a CBC radio host and journalist before publishing Still Life (2005), the first of her Chief Inspector Armand Gamache novels, set mostly in the fictional Quebec village of Three Pines. Still Life won the CWA New Blood Dagger, and she has since won the Agatha Award, named for Christie, five times. The series reached The Black Wolf in 2025.

Christie's village — the small place where everyone has a secret and the newcomer notices most — moved to rural Quebec and given more weight. Penny keeps the large cast and the red herrings, but she lets grief and kindness take up as much room as the puzzle. Readers who loved Miss Marple usually love Three Pines.

— Lisanne
10
And Then There Were None, rebuilt

Yukito Ayatsuji

Japanese · b. 1960 · Mystery novelist

In The Decagon House Murders, seven members of a university mystery club, known to each other by the names of Western crime writers — Agatha, Carr, Ellery, Leroux, Orczy, Poe and Van Dine — spend a week on an island where a murder was never solved, and begin to die one by one. The novel is widely credited with starting Japan's shin honkaku (“new orthodox”) movement, a return to the classic puzzle. Ho-Ling Wong's English translation appeared in 2015 and was reissued by Pushkin Vertigo in 2020.

The most direct descendant of And Then There Were None in print: the isolated island, the deaths in sequence, the confession in a bottle, all openly borrowed and then turned. It is a pure puzzle in Christie's sense, with nothing hidden from the reader, and its final twist is one of the best in the genre.

— Lisanne

Where to start if you loved Agatha Christie

If you want Christie's own era, read Dorothy L. Sayers.

Strong Poison, then Gaudy Night: the same fair-play rigour with more novel around it.

If you want her written now, read Richard Osman.

The Thursday Murder Club: Miss Marple's village as a retirement home in Kent.

If you want the machinery on show, read Anthony Horowitz.

Magpie Murders: a Christie-style mystery inside a mystery about it.

If you want And Then There Were None again, read Yukito Ayatsuji.

The Decagon House Murders: an island, a club of mystery fans, and no way off.

Frequently asked questions about authors like Agatha Christie

Who should I read if I love Agatha Christie?

Dorothy L. Sayers first: she was Christie's contemporary, a fellow founder member of the Detection Club, and wrote fair-play puzzles with more room for character. Ngaio Marsh and Margery Allingham, the other two Golden Age “Queens of Crime”, come next. For modern writers in her tradition, read Richard Osman, Anthony Horowitz and Louise Penny.

What books are like And Then There Were None?

Yukito Ayatsuji's The Decagon House Murders (1987) is the closest: a group of students on an isolated island, killed one by one, written as an open tribute to Christie's novel. Anthony Horowitz's Magpie Murders (2016) is the best modern novel built on her methods, though it is closer to her village mysteries than to the island.

Who were the Queens of Crime?

Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Ngaio Marsh and Margery Allingham, the four women who dominated British detective fiction in its Golden Age between the wars. Christie and Sayers were founder members of the Detection Club in 1930 and Allingham joined in 1934; Marsh, who lived in New Zealand, was not inducted until 1974.

What was the Detection Club?

A society of British detective writers founded in 1930, with G. K. Chesterton as its first president. Members swore an oath that their detectives would solve crimes by their own wits rather than by coincidence or “Divine Revelation”, the fair-play principle Christie's books are built on. Sayers was its president from 1949 to 1957 and Christie from 1957 until her death in 1976. It still exists.

Are there modern authors like Agatha Christie?

Yes. Richard Osman's Thursday Murder Club series is the closest in tone, Anthony Horowitz's Magpie Murders books rebuild her structure deliberately, and Louise Penny's Three Pines novels move the village mystery to Quebec. Yukito Ayatsuji's The Decagon House Murders started a whole Japanese movement devoted to the classic puzzle.

Who writes like Agatha Christie but darker?

P.D. James and Ruth Rendell. James kept the closed circle of suspects but gave everyone in it a full inner life; Rendell, who openly disliked Christie's books, cared more about why an ordinary person kills than about who did it. Margery Allingham's The Tiger in the Smoke is the darkest of the Golden Age novels.

Have Agatha Christie's books been changed?

Some have. And Then There Were None took its first British title from a nursery rhyme that used a racial slur; it has long been published under its present title. In 2023 The Telegraph reported that HarperCollins had revised several of her novels, with sensitivity readers removing passages containing ethnic descriptions and insults.

Footnotes

Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. Every comparison here is a judgement about method and subject, not an algorithmic match. See more on her personal bookshelf.

From the bookshelf

More writers worth your time.

If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.

Browse the full bookshelf Get book recommendations
Start Typing