Reading List

Authors Like Jodi Picoult

Jodi Picoult's Nineteen Minutes (2007) opens with a shooting at the high school in Sterling, a fictional New Hampshire town, and spends the rest of the book on the people around it: the boy who did it, his mother, the girl who used to be his friend, the detective and the defence lawyer. Picoult used the 1997 Heath High School shooting in Kentucky and Columbine as research, and the novel has since become, according to PEN America, the book most often removed from American school shelves. That is the shape of most of her books since her first, Songs of the Humpback Whale, in 1992: an issue that splits a dinner table — a child conceived to save her sister in My Sister's Keeper (2004), a Black nurse barred from touching a white supremacist couple's baby in Small Great Things (2016) — handed to one family, told in several voices, and very often settled in a courtroom. Her new novel, Hollow Bones, published in September 2026, brings back Jesse Fitzgerald, the troubled older brother from My Sister's Keeper. The writers below share some part of that: a moral question nobody can answer cleanly, a family that has to live inside it, and a plot that keeps you turning pages to see who will be judged.

By Lisanne Swart · 10 authors · Family drama · Moral dilemmas · Courtroom fiction · Updated October 2026


Quick answer

If you love Jodi Picoult, start with Chris Bohjalian, whose Midwives puts a mother on trial and tells it through her daughter. For Nineteen Minutes, read Lionel Shriver's We Need to Talk About Kevin. For the town that turns on itself, Celeste Ng and Liane Moriarty. And for Small Great Things, Tayari Jones's An American Marriage, a wrongful conviction told by the people it breaks apart.

10 authors like Jodi Picoult

01
Closest match · The trial as family story

Chris Bohjalian

American · b. 1962 · Novelist

Bohjalian was born in White Plains, New York, in 1962 and has lived in Vermont since 1988. In Midwives, a rural Vermont midwife performs an emergency Caesarean on a patient she believes has already died, and is tried for involuntary manslaughter; the story is told by her fourteen-year-old daughter. It was chosen for Oprah's Book Club in October 1998. The Flight Attendant became a television series with Kaley Cuoco in 2020.

The nearest thing to a Picoult novel written by someone else: a New England setting, a professional decision made in seconds, and a trial that asks whether it was right, seen from inside the family that pays for it. Bohjalian is a little cooler and more interested in procedure, but the moral weight lands in the same place — on the child watching.

— Lisanne
02
One event, many voices

Anita Shreve

American · b. 1946 · Novelist

Shreve was born in Boston in 1946 and died in New Hampshire in 2018. The Weight of Water (1997) won the PEN New England fiction award and was filmed by Kathryn Bigelow; The Pilot's Wife, about a woman who learns what her husband was hiding only after his plane goes down, was an Oprah's Book Club pick in 1999. Testimony follows a sex scandal at a Massachusetts prep school and its cover-up through the voices of the students, parents and staff involved.

Testimony is the book to start with: a single bad night examined from a dozen points of view, with no clean line between victim, culprit and bystander. That rotating structure is exactly what Picoult uses, and Shreve's prose is quieter and more literary while keeping the same pull. (She did not write The Pact — that is Picoult's own 1998 novel.)

— Lisanne

Every book by Anita Shreve →

03
The Nineteen Minutes pairing

Lionel Shriver

American · b. 1957 · Novelist · Women's Prize 2005

Shriver was born in Gastonia, North Carolina, in 1957 and lived for decades in the United Kingdom before moving to Portugal in 2023. We Need to Talk About Kevin is told in letters from a mother to her husband after their fifteen-year-old son has carried out a massacre at his school; it won the Orange Prize (now the Women's Prize) in 2005 and was filmed in 2011 with Tilda Swinton. So Much for That, about an American family bankrupted by illness, was a National Book Award finalist.

The darker sibling of Nineteen Minutes. Both novels ask what a parent knew and could have done; Picoult spreads that question across a town and a courtroom, while Shriver keeps it inside one mother's head and refuses her any comfort. It is a harder, colder book, and a more uncomfortable one about motherhood.

— Lisanne
04
Suburban secrets, with a dark laugh

Liane Moriarty

Australian · b. 1966 · Novelist

Moriarty was born in 1966 and grew up in Sydney. Big Little Lies follows three mothers of kindergarten children in the months before a death at a school fundraiser, and was adapted by HBO in 2017 with Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman and Shailene Woodley. She was the first Australian author to debut at number one on the New York Times bestseller list. Her most recent novel is Here One Moment (2024).

The same engine as Picoult — an ordinary community, a hidden wrong, a slow reveal of who knew what — run with comedy instead of gravity. Moriarty is lighter on the page and sharper about social ranking, but the moral questions under the jokes are just as serious, especially about domestic violence in Big Little Lies.

— Lisanne

Every book by Liane Moriarty →

05
A custody fight that splits a town

Celeste Ng

American · b. 1980 · Novelist

Ng was born in Pittsburgh in 1980. Everything I Never Told You, about a Chinese-American family in 1970s Ohio after their daughter's death, was Amazon's book of the year in 2014. Little Fires Everywhere is set in Shaker Heights, Ohio, where a white family's attempt to adopt an abandoned Chinese-American baby becomes a custody case that divides the town. Our Missing Hearts (2022) is set in a near-future America hostile to Asian Americans.

Little Fires Everywhere is built the way Picoult builds a book: a legal case about a child, two mothers with real claims, and a whole community taking sides. Ng is a more careful stylist and less interested in the verdict than in what it reveals about class and race, which makes her a natural next step after Small Great Things.

— Lisanne

Every book by Celeste Ng →

06
The medical dilemma, from the inside

Lisa Genova

American · b. 1970 · Novelist

Genova, born in 1970, has a PhD in neuroscience from Harvard. She self-published Still Alice, about a Harvard linguistics professor with early-onset Alzheimer's, in 2007; Simon & Schuster reissued it in 2009, and Julianne Moore won the Academy Award for Best Actress for the 2014 film. Her other novels each follow a family through one neurological condition, including ALS in Every Note Played and Huntington's in Inside the O'Briens (2015).

For readers who love the hospital half of Picoult — the diagnosis, the treatment decision, the family arguing in the corridor. Genova researches the medicine with the same thoroughness and writes it with more precision, but there is no courtroom: the question is not who is to blame but how a family lives with what cannot be fixed.

— Lisanne

Every book by Lisa Genova →

07
A wrongful conviction, in three voices

Tayari Jones

American · b. 1970 · Novelist · Women's Prize 2019

Jones was born in Atlanta in 1970. An American Marriage follows a young Black couple in the South whose marriage is broken when the husband is convicted of a crime he did not commit; it was an Oprah's Book Club pick on its publication day in 2018 and won the Women's Prize for Fiction in 2019. Her novel Kin (2026), about two friends from small-town Louisiana, won the 2026 Kirkus Prize for fiction.

The best book to read after Small Great Things. Like Picoult, Jones takes the justice system's failure and makes it a family matter, told in alternating first-person voices that each have a case to make. Unlike Picoult, she writes Black lives from inside, and the moral question — what a wife owes a husband who was taken from her — is left with the reader.

— Lisanne
08
The custody case that started it

Sue Miller

American · b. 1943 · Novelist

Miller was born in Chicago in 1943. In The Good Mother, her first novel, a divorced woman loses custody of her young daughter after her ex-husband accuses her new lover of improper behaviour with the child; it was filmed in 1988 with Diane Keaton and Liam Neeson. While I Was Gone, about a veterinarian whose past is reopened by an old housemate's murder, was an Oprah's Book Club pick in 2000.

The Good Mother is an ancestor of the Picoult novel: a family court case in which every adult has some right on their side and a child pays for all of it. Miller is slower, more interior and more literary, with no twist at the end — the same moral seriousness in a quieter register.

— Lisanne

Every book by Sue Miller →

09
Family secrets with a historical root

Diane Chamberlain

American · b. 1950 · Novelist

Chamberlain was born in Plainfield, New Jersey, in 1950 and trained as a clinical social worker, working in hospitals and then running a psychotherapy practice for adolescents before writing full-time. Necessary Lies is set in rural North Carolina around 1960, where a new county social worker discovers that a fifteen-year-old girl in her care is in line for the state's eugenics sterilisation programme. Many of her novels pair a present-day story with a buried one from the past.

Chamberlain shares Picoult's instinct for a plot built around a decision with no good option, and her social-work background shows in how precisely she draws families under pressure. Necessary Lies is the most Picoult-like: a real, documented injustice, a professional caught between rules and conscience, and a teenage girl at the centre.

— Lisanne

Every book by Diane Chamberlain →

10
The missing child

Jacquelyn Mitchard

American · b. 1953 · Novelist

Mitchard grew up near Chicago and worked as a journalist. The Deep End of the Ocean follows a family after their three-year-old son vanishes from a hotel lobby, and what happens when a boy turns up nine years later under another name; in September 1996 it became the first ever selection of Oprah's Book Club, and it was filmed with Michelle Pfeiffer.

The book that opened the door Picoult walked through: a family drama with a moral knot at its centre — who does a child belong to, the family he was born into or the one that raised him — written for the same broad readership. Mitchard stays closer to the home than the courtroom, but the question is pure Picoult.

— Lisanne

Where to start if you loved Jodi Picoult

If you want My Sister's Keeper again, read Chris Bohjalian.

Midwives: a mother on trial, seen through her daughter's eyes.

If you want Nineteen Minutes without the comfort, read Lionel Shriver.

We Need to Talk About Kevin — the shooter's mother, writing it down.

If you want Small Great Things, read Tayari Jones.

An American Marriage: a wrongful conviction and the marriage it breaks.

If you want the secrets with a laugh, read Liane Moriarty.

Big Little Lies, one school fundraiser at a time.

Frequently asked questions about authors like Jodi Picoult

Who should I read if I love Jodi Picoult?

Chris Bohjalian is the closest match: Midwives (1997) puts a Vermont midwife on trial and tells it through her daughter. Anita Shreve's Testimony uses Picoult's many-voices structure on a school scandal. For particular books, read Lionel Shriver after Nineteen Minutes, Tayari Jones after Small Great Things, and Celeste Ng or Liane Moriarty for a whole community taking sides.

What books are like My Sister's Keeper?

Chris Bohjalian's Midwives is the closest: a medical decision, a trial, and a child narrating what it does to her family. Lisa Genova's Still Alice and Every Note Played follow families through a diagnosis with the same care for the medicine. Jacquelyn Mitchard's The Deep End of the Ocean asks a similar question about who a child belongs to.

What books are like Nineteen Minutes?

Lionel Shriver's We Need to Talk About Kevin (2003) is the obvious pairing: a school massacre seen through the eyes of the killer's mother. Anita Shreve's Testimony (2008) tells a school scandal through students, parents and staff, much as Picoult tells the shooting through the town of Sterling.

What books are like Small Great Things?

Tayari Jones's An American Marriage (2018) turns a wrongful conviction into a family story told in several voices, and won the Women's Prize in 2019. Celeste Ng's Little Fires Everywhere (2017) uses a custody case over a Chinese-American baby to expose race and class in an Ohio suburb.

Did Anita Shreve write The Pact?

No. The Pact (1998) is a Jodi Picoult novel, about two families after a teenage couple's apparent suicide pact. The confusion is common because Shreve and Picoult were both New England novelists writing family drama in the same years. The Shreve book closest to Picoult is Testimony (2008).

Why is Nineteen Minutes banned in some schools?

PEN America has listed Nineteen Minutes as the book most often removed from US school libraries and classrooms, in the 2023–24 school year and since. Picoult has said the challenges focus on a single page describing a date rape, not on the school shooting, and points out that the novel was once taught in some of the same schools that now remove it.

What is Jodi Picoult's newest book?

Hollow Bones, published by Ballantine on 15 September 2026. It brings back Jesse Fitzgerald, the troubled brother from My Sister's Keeper, now a detective in Providence, Rhode Island, and centres on a family drama shaped by the 11 September attacks. Before that came By Any Other Name (2024), about a woman writer behind Shakespeare's plays.

Footnotes

Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. Every comparison here is a judgement about method and subject, not an algorithmic match. See more on her personal bookshelf.

From the bookshelf

More writers worth your time.

If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.

Browse the full bookshelf Get book recommendations
Start Typing