Reading List
Authors Like
In December 1849 Dostoevsky was taken to a square in St Petersburg, tied to a post and told he would be shot for belonging to a circle that discussed banned books. The first three men were bound to stakes; he was in the second group. At the last moment an officer rode up with a letter: the Tsar had commuted the sentences and the entire execution had been staged. One of the condemned lost his mind on the spot. Dostoevsky served four years at hard labour in Omsk and came back with epilepsy, a religious conviction and the subject he never left — what a person will do, and believe, once they have decided the rules do not apply to them. Notes from Underground (1864) invented a voice nobody had written before. Crime and Punishment (1866) is a student who murders a pawnbroker to prove a theory and spends four hundred pages being followed by a detective who never quite accuses him. The Idiot, Demons and The Brothers Karamazov followed; he died two months after finishing the last one. He also gambled away everything he had, repeatedly. The ten below are chosen on moral extremity and on who is arguing with him.
By Lisanne Swart · 10 authors · Russian fiction · Five major novels · Which translation to read · Updated October 2026
Quick answer
The eternal pairing is with Leo Tolstoy, and the argument about which is greater has run for a century and a half. Nikolai Gogol is the Russian he came out of and Anton Chekhov the one who came after. Three writers in other languages took the underground man somewhere new, two Americans inherited the violence and the grace, and one great Russian novelist spent his career telling students that Dostoevsky was overrated.
Where to start if you loved Fyodor Dostoevsky
If you want the other great Russian, read Leo Tolstoy.
Anna Karenina. Daylight where Dostoevsky gives you fever.
If you want where he came from, read Nikolai Gogol.
“The Overcoat”. A clerk, a stolen coat, and an hour of your time.
If you loved Notes from Underground, read Albert Camus.
The Fall. A monologue in an Amsterdam bar that accuses you personally.
If you want the camps, read Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn.
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich. Reveille to lights out, under two hundred pages.
If you want the argument against him, read Vladimir Nabokov.
The Cornell lectures. A great Russian novelist taking him apart in detail.
If you want more novels of this kind
My shelf of the best fiction has the rest.
10 authors like Fyodor Dostoevsky
Frequently asked questions about authors like Fyodor Dostoevsky
Who should I read if I love Dostoevsky?
Leo Tolstoy is the permanent pairing, Nikolai Gogol is the Russian he came out of and Anton Chekhov the one who came after, with the ideas replaced by silence. Franz Kafka is the direct heir of Notes from Underground and Albert Camus asked the same question in French. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn is the twentieth-century descendant of The House of the Dead. Flannery O'Connor stages the same theology inside a crime story and Cormac McCarthy took the Grand Inquisitor into the desert. Viktor Frankl answers Ivan Karamazov from Auschwitz. Vladimir Nabokov is the argument against.
Which translation of Crime and Punishment should I read?
Three are in wide circulation and they are genuinely different books. Constance Garnett's, from 1914, is smooth, Victorian and sometimes simplifies what she found difficult — beautiful, not precise. Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky's, revised for the bicentenary, is the standard scholarly choice and keeps the strangeness of the Russian, which some readers find stiff. Michael R. Katz's, the newest, aims at contemporary American English and is the easiest for a reader in 2026, with the psychology landing hardest. If you have bounced off the novel before, try Katz.
Which Dostoevsky should I start with?
Crime and Punishment (1866), which has a murder on page seventy and a detective who never quite accuses anyone, and is far more gripping than its reputation. Notes from Underground (1864) is about a hundred and fifty pages and contains the voice that changed twentieth-century fiction, but it is deliberately unpleasant company. The Brothers Karamazov (1880) is the masterpiece and it is eight hundred pages; come to it third. The Idiot and Demons are for when you are committed.
Was he really almost executed?
Yes. In December 1849, at twenty-eight, he was convicted for involvement with the Petrashevsky circle, a discussion group that read banned material, and taken to Semyonovsky Square to be shot. The first three men were tied to stakes and the order was given before a messenger arrived with a commutation from the Tsar — the whole thing had been staged on the Tsar's instruction. One prisoner never recovered his reason. Dostoevsky then spent four years at hard labour in Omsk, which produced The House of the Dead and, by his own account, his faith.
What is the Grand Inquisitor?
A chapter near the middle of The Brothers Karamazov in which Ivan tells his devout brother Alyosha a story he has invented: Christ returns during the Spanish Inquisition, is arrested, and is told by the old Inquisitor that the Church has corrected his work, because people do not want freedom, they want bread, mystery and someone to obey. It is about twenty pages, it can be read on its own, and it is the single most argued-over passage in the novel. Camus, Frankl and McCarthy are all, in different ways, answering it.
What is the criticism of Dostoevsky?
That the writing is hasty and the effects are cheap. He wrote fast and under contract — The Gambler was dictated in twenty-six days to clear a debt — and the prose shows it; the coincidences are wild, characters arrive to deliver philosophy and leave, and the emotional pressure can feel applied rather than earned. Nabokov made the case at length in his Cornell lectures. The defence is that the questions are the largest anyone has asked in a novel and that no one else has got near them.
Is there a good recent adaptation?
Not really, which is unusual for a writer this famous. A Russian series of Crime and Punishment was made for Kinopoisk in 2024 with a troubled release history and is hard to see outside Russia. The standing stage version by Marilyn Campbell and Curt Columbus compresses the novel to ninety minutes with three actors and is revived regularly by small companies. For once the honest advice is to read the book.
In what order should I read the novels?
Notes from Underground, then Crime and Punishment, then The Brothers Karamazov is the standard route and it works. If you want them chronologically: Poor Folk (1846), The House of the Dead (1862), Notes from Underground (1864), Crime and Punishment (1866), The Gambler (1867), The Idiot (1869), Demons (1872) and The Brothers Karamazov (1880). He died two months after finishing the last.
Footnotes
- Crime and Punishment, translated by Michael R. Katz — publisher description and translator biography
- The best translation of Crime and Punishment: a reader's guide — July 2026
- Crime and Punishment: what it is about and the best translation — reviewed June 2026
- Fyodor Dostoevsky — biography and bibliography, with the Petrashevsky arrest
- Crime and Punishment (2024 TV series) — Wikipedia
List last reviewed 23 September 2026.
More from the shelf
From the bookshelf
“Beauty will save the world.”
— Fyodor Dostoevsky, The Idiot, 1869.
If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.
Browse the full bookshelf Get book recommendations