Author Guide · True Crime & Longform Journalism

Books Written by Jeff Maysh

In 2018 Jeff Maysh published an 8,700-word story in The Daily Beast about an ex-cop who rigged the McDonald’s Monopoly game, and within a week 20th Century Fox and Ben Affleck and Matt Damon’s company Pearl Street Films had bid $1 million for the film rights. Maysh, a British-American journalist born in Nassau in 1982 and raised in south London, started at the men’s magazine Loaded, reported for the BBC, and moved to the United States in 2010 to cover crime. Most of his work is magazine longform for The Atlantic, The New Yorker and others, about bank robbers, spies and fraudsters with secret lives. His two Kindle Singles give two of those cases the length of a short book. This guide covers his two key books, in order, and where to begin.

By Lisanne Swart · 2 key books · 2016–2017 · Updated 7 Nov: notes in the margin


Quick answer

Jeff Maysh has published two short books, both Kindle Singles: Handsome Devil (2016), about the con man Victor Lustig, and The Spy With No Name (2017), about the Cold War agent Erwin van Haarlem.

His best-known work is not a book but his 2018 Daily Beast story on the McDonald’s Monopoly fraud.

2 Jeff Maysh Books, in Order

01
True crime · Kindle Single

Handsome Devil

Jeff Maysh · 2016

If you want a con man too audacious to be invented, start here.Start here!

The true story of “Count” Victor Lustig, the Jazz Age con man and counterfeiter best remembered for selling the Eiffel Tower to scrap dealers. Maysh follows his schemes and escapes from the law up to the manhunt led by J. Edgar Hoover. It grew out of Maysh’s reporting on Lustig for Smithsonian, “The Man Who Sold the Eiffel Tower. Twice”, and is also available as an audiobook.

Get the bookAmazonBookshop.org
Waterstones, bol.com, AudibleMore shops
02
Espionage · Kindle Single

The Spy With No Name: The Cold War and a Case of Stolen Identity

Jeff Maysh · 2017

If you want Cold War espionage, this is your book.For Cold War espionage!

The true story of Erwin van Haarlem, a Communist agent who lived in Britain under a stolen identity to gather British and American military secrets. In 1977 a woman named Johanna van Haarlem found him and believed he was the son she had given up during the Second World War. Maysh tracked the former spy down in Prague to reconstruct the eleven-year deception. A shorter version ran on BBC News in January 2017.

Get the bookAmazonBookshop.org
Waterstones, bol.com, AudibleMore shops

In What Order to Read Jeff Maysh

The two books are separate cases and do not depend on each other, so the order hardly matters. Publication order works well: Handsome Devil is the lighter, faster story, and The Spy With No Name adds what Maysh is best at, finding the person at the centre of the case and getting them to talk.

Both are short enough to read in an evening. After that, the natural next step is his magazine work, starting with the McDonald’s Monopoly story, which runs to nearly 9,000 words and reads the same way.

A reading path
1. Handsome Devil (2016)
2. The Spy With No Name (2017)
3. “How an Ex-Cop Rigged McDonald’s Monopoly Game and Stole Millions”, The Daily Beast (2018)

Everything Else Jeff Maysh Published

Beyond the 2 key books: 1 more, grouped by kind.

Open a group with the + to see every book in it.

Early book

1

1 book · 2010

  1. 2010Lilywhite and Bluea history of Tottenham Hotspur’s famous shirt

The years · 1982–2022

Quick facts about Jeff Maysh

Known for
Jeff Maysh is known for longform true-crime stories about people leading double lives, above all his 2018 account of the McDonald’s Monopoly fraud.
1982
Born in Nassau, Bahamas
2022
“The $30 Million Lotto Scam” in The Atlantic
Born
30 March 1982, Nassau, Bahamas; grew up in south London
Nationality
British-American
Based in
Southern California
Started at
Loaded magazine, then the BBC
Writes for
The Atlantic, The New Yorker, Smithsonian, Bloomberg Businessweek, The Daily Beast
Honours
Five Southern California Journalism Awards, including Best Crime Reporting twice

The red mark is 2016: Handsome Devil, his first Kindle Single.

How Jeff Maysh Writes: Double Lives in Three Acts

Maysh has no formal journalism training. He grew up in south London around police work, and has said that when he was 14 a close family member, an undercover police officer, went to prison, and he visited him there often. His subjects since have almost all lived double lives: a bank robber, a spy under a borrowed name, a sweepstakes cop. As he told Nieman Storyboard, that is a world he already knew how to look into.

He builds stories the way a screenwriter would, with a three-act structure, scenes and dialogue, which he has given as the reason so many of his articles are optioned. The reporting underneath is documentary: court files, archives and, whenever possible, the criminal in person, as with the former spy he traced to Prague. He is open about the risk of relying on such sources, saying a writer must make clear when someone is an unreliable narrator and let the reader decide.

Because his books are short and few, most readers come to him through the magazine pieces and stay for the genre. For writers who work the same seam of con artists, spies and reported true crime, see Authors like Jeff Maysh.

Listen

Jeff Maysh on the Longform Podcast

Jeff Maysh talks on the Longform Podcast in August 2018 about his story of the ex-policeman who rigged the McDonald’s Monopoly game and his interest in people who live double lives. From the archive of the Longform Podcast.

Frequently asked questions about Jeff Maysh’s books

How many books has Jeff Maysh written?

Two key books, both Kindle Singles: Handsome Devil (2016), about con man Victor Lustig, and The Spy With No Name (2017), about Cold War agent Erwin van Haarlem. Earlier he published Lilywhite and Blue (2010), a history of Tottenham Hotspur’s shirt. Most of his output is longform magazine journalism.

What are Jeff Maysh’s books in order?

Handsome Devil (2016) and The Spy With No Name: The Cold War and a Case of Stolen Identity (2017).

Where should I start with Jeff Maysh?

Handsome Devil. It is the shorter route into his method: a criminal who sounds invented, reconstructed from the record. If you prefer espionage, start with The Spy With No Name instead.

What is Jeff Maysh’s most famous work?

Not a book but a magazine story: “How an Ex-Cop Rigged McDonald’s Monopoly Game and Stole Millions”, published in The Daily Beast in July 2018. Of his books, Handsome Devil is the better known.

Is the McDonald’s Monopoly story being made into a film?

The film rights were bought in 2018: 20th Century Fox and Pearl Street Films, the company of Ben Affleck and Matt Damon, bid $1 million for Maysh’s Daily Beast story, with Affleck attached to direct and Damon to star. The Hollywood Reporter called it one of the most lucrative rights deals ever for a single article.

Is Jeff Maysh primarily a book author or a magazine writer?

Primarily a magazine writer. He writes longform journalism about crime, espionage and fraud for The Atlantic, The New Yorker, Smithsonian, Bloomberg Businessweek, MIT Technology Review and others, and his two Kindle Singles extend that same reporting into short books.

What subjects does Jeff Maysh usually write about?

Con artists, spies, bank robbers and elaborate frauds — real people living double lives. Examples include “The Wedding Sting” (The Atlantic, 2015), the DuckTales bandit Dagobert (The New Yorker, 2021) and “The $30 Million Lotto Scam” (The Atlantic, 2022).

Has Jeff Maysh won any awards?

Yes. He has won five Southern California Journalism Awards, including Best Crime Reporting twice. His BBC story “The Bombshell Bandit” was named best crime story of 2015 by Longform.org, and his story on footballer Steve Davies was listed in Best American Sports Writing 2014.

Where is Jeff Maysh from?

He was born on 30 March 1982 in Nassau, Bahamas, grew up in south London, and moved to the United States in 2010. He is British-American and lives in Southern California.

Follow the thread

Authors like Jeff Maysh: ten writers to read next

Start with David Grann: the same obsession, at book length, and the closest match.

Go deeper →

Footnotes

This list was not put together by a machine.
The notes are all mine,
and the books are all his.

Lisanne x

Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. Titles, dates and details are checked against the publication record.
See more on her personal bookshelf.

From the bookshelf
“All of the people I write about are leading double lives, so I kind of know where to look.”

— Jeff Maysh, interview with Nieman Storyboard

If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.

Have a look at my shelf Send me the next one
Start Typing