Reading List

Authors Like Jeff Maysh

In July 2018 the Daily Beast published nearly nine thousand words by Maysh about Jerome Jacobson, the former police officer hired to run security on the McDonald's Monopoly promotion, who spent more than a decade quietly handing the winning game pieces to a network of relatives, mobsters and strangers and stole around twenty million dollars in cash and prizes. Within a week, 20th Century Fox and Ben Affleck and Matt Damon's Pearl Street Films had paid a reported million dollars for the rights, beating Universal, Netflix and Warner Bros., with Affleck to direct and Damon to star. The trial had begun the day before 11 September 2001, which is why almost nobody remembered it. Maysh was born in the Bahamas in 1982, is British-American, lives in Southern California and works as an associate creative director in the technology industry alongside the journalism — a double life, which is also his subject. He has written for The New Yorker, The Atlantic, the Financial Times, Bloomberg Businessweek, Smithsonian, the BBC and MIT Technology Review: a Czechoslovak spy who lived for years as another man, the confidence trickster who sold the Eiffel Tower twice, a CIA plot to steal a Soviet satellite overnight. Harvard's Nieman Storyboard described him as drawn to genre-breaking stories about people with secret lives. There is no full-length book yet, which is why this page exists.

By Lisanne Swart · 10 authors · Longform true crime · Southern California · Magazine to movie · Updated September 2026


Quick answer

If you love Jeff Maysh, the closest match is David Grann: magazine-length obsessions about people who disappeared into an idea, expanded into books and then into films. Patrick Radden Keefe is the other great New Yorker reporter working the same seam, and Susan Orlean the funniest. For the short single-caper book, read Michael Finkel. For espionage and double lives, read Ben Macintyre. And Janet Malcolm's The Journalist and the Murderer is the argument against the whole enterprise, made by someone who knew it from the inside.

Every book by Jeff Maysh →

10 authors like Jeff Maysh

01
The same obsession, at book length · Closest match

David Grann

American · The Lost City of Z (2009), Killers of the Flower Moon (2017), The Wager (2023)

Grann is a staff writer at The New Yorker whose books usually begin as magazine pieces. The Lost City of Z follows the explorer Percy Fawcett into the Amazon and Grann after him; Killers of the Flower Moon reconstructs the murders of Osage people for their oil headrights in 1920s Oklahoma and the young Bureau of Investigation case that followed, and Martin Scorsese filmed it in 2023; The Wager is a shipwreck, a mutiny and two competing accounts delivered to the Admiralty.

The best possible next writer, and the model for the career Maysh appears to be building. Both find a forgotten crime in an archive, establish that it is stranger than any invention, and report it until the characters are people rather than anecdotes. Grann has done at book length what Maysh has so far done at magazine length, and the film pipeline runs the same way. Start with Killers of the Flower Moon and read the last section slowly.

— Lisanne

Every book by David Grann →

Authors like David Grann →

02
The reporter who stays for years

Patrick Radden Keefe

American · Say Nothing (2018), Empire of Pain (2021), Rogues (2022)

Say Nothing uses the 1972 abduction and murder of Jean McConville in Belfast to tell the Troubles through the people who carried it out, and became an FX series in 2024. Empire of Pain is three generations of the Sackler family and the marketing of OxyContin, and won the Baillie Gifford Prize. Rogues collects twelve of his magazine pieces, which is the closest thing on this list to a Maysh anthology: an arms dealer, a wine forger, a chef, a bank robber.

The most useful single volume for a Maysh reader is Rogues, because it is the same form done at the highest level — one improbable person per chapter, reported until the improbability becomes explicable. Keefe is more interested in institutions and consequences than Maysh, whose stories usually stop when the handcuffs go on. Read Rogues first and Say Nothing when you have a week.

— Lisanne

Every book by Patrick Radden Keefe →

Authors like Patrick Radden Keefe →

03
The same curiosity, funnier

Susan Orlean

American · The Orchid Thief (1998), The Library Book (2018)

The Orchid Thief began as a New Yorker piece about a Florida plant dealer arrested for stealing rare orchids from a state preserve, and became a book and then Adaptation (2002), a film about the impossibility of adapting it. The Library Book is built around the 1986 fire that destroyed much of the Los Angeles Central Library and the man accused of setting it, and turns into a history of libraries themselves. She has been at The New Yorker since 1992.

What happens when the same nose for an eccentric is attached to a writer more interested in why people are like this than in how the crime was done. Orlean and Maysh both go looking for someone with a private obsession and both find the wider world attached to it. She is the better company on the page and the less propulsive storyteller. If the counterfeit Queen of Soul or the catfishing story were your favourites, read her.

— Lisanne

Every book by Susan Orlean →

Authors like Susan Orlean →

04
One caper, one short book

Michael Finkel

American · True Story (2005), The Stranger in the Woods (2017), The Art Thief (2023)

Finkel writes short books about single strange lives: a man who lived alone in the Maine woods for twenty-seven years and stole what he needed from holiday cabins; a Frenchman who took more than two hundred artworks from European museums, largely because he wanted them. True Story is about a murderer who used Finkel's name while on the run, which Finkel learned about days after The New York Times Magazine dismissed him in 2002 for building a composite character in a story about West African cocoa labour.

The closest match in shape: two hundred pages, one person, one long improbable act, told cleanly. Finkel writes exactly the book a Maysh magazine piece would become. He is also the cautionary example on this list — the composite that ended his newspaper career is documented, he has written about it, and it is worth knowing before you decide how much to trust a scene.

— Lisanne

Every book by Michael Finkel →

Authors like Michael Finkel →

05
Double lives, professionally

Ben Macintyre

British · Agent Zigzag (2007), Operation Mincemeat (2010), The Spy and the Traitor (2018)

Macintyre works from declassified British and Soviet files and writes espionage as character comedy with lethal stakes: a safecracker turned double agent, a corpse dressed as a Royal Marine officer to deceive the Germans about Sicily, Kim Philby's friendship with the man who did not see it, and Oleg Gordievsky's exfiltration from Moscow in a car boot. He is a columnist at The Times, and several of the books have been filmed, including Operation Mincemeat in 2021.

The espionage half of Maysh's work, done at scale. Maysh's piece on the Czechoslovak agent who lived for years under a dead child's name is precisely a Macintyre subject, and both writers are drawn to the same thing: the ordinary person maintaining an impossible second identity, and the moment it collapses. Macintyre has the archives and the page count; Maysh has the tighter narrative discipline.

— Lisanne

Every book by Ben Macintyre →

06
The Texas magazine tradition

Skip Hollandsworth

American · The Midnight Assassin (2016)

Hollandsworth has spent decades at Texas Monthly writing long true crime pieces about small Texan places, and his article about Bernie Tiede, an East Texas funeral director convicted of killing the wealthy widow he had befriended, became Richard Linklater's Bernie (2011), which he co-wrote. The Midnight Assassin is about a series of murders in Austin in the 1880s, years before the Whitechapel killings in London, and the city that could not catch the killer.

The magazine-to-film route Maysh has made his method, run for thirty years by one writer at one magazine. Hollandsworth is the great living practitioner of the small-town American crime story, and his work shows what the form gains when the reporter already knows the county. If you want to see the pipeline Maysh teaches, this is the person who built it quietly and first.

— Lisanne
07
The piece that became the film

Mark Bowden

American · Black Hawk Down (1999), Killing Pablo (2001), Hue 1968 (2017)

Black Hawk Down began as a twenty-nine-part series in The Philadelphia Inquirer reconstructing the 1993 raid in Mogadishu almost minute by minute from hundreds of interviews and radio transcripts, and became a book and then Ridley Scott's 2001 film. Killing Pablo follows the hunt for Pablo Escobar. He spent twenty years as a newspaper reporter before the books, and has written for The Atlantic and Vanity Fair since.

The original version of what happened to Maysh in 2018: a newspaper reporter's long piece turning into a book and then into a major film, on the strength of the reporting rather than a pitch. Bowden also demonstrates the ceiling of the form — he interviewed everyone, on both sides, and the result holds up as history rather than as a treatment. Read him for what the method can reach.

— Lisanne

Every book by Mark Bowden →

Authors like Mark Bowden →

08
Older than the genre · People with secret lives

Joseph Mitchell

American · McSorley's Wonderful Saloon (1943), Joe Gould's Secret (1965)

Mitchell wrote for The New Yorker about the fringes of the city: fish market workers, a bearded lady, the tenants of a Bowery hotel, and above all Joe Gould, a Harvard-educated vagrant who claimed to be writing the longest book in existence, an oral history of the world. Mitchell wrote about him twice, decades apart, and the second piece reveals what he had learned. He also acknowledged that some of his figures were composites drawn from several people, which changed how the profiles are read.

The ancestor of the Maysh sensibility, and the phrase Nieman Storyboard used about him — people with secret lives — is Mitchell's entire subject. He is slower, sadder and better than almost anyone here, and Joe Gould's Secret is also the best short book ever written about what a reporter owes a subject who is not entirely well. Read it after the Maysh piece about the man who lived under another name.

— Lisanne

Every book by Joseph Mitchell →

09
The same pipeline, faster and looser

Ben Mezrich

American · Bringing Down the House (2002), The Accidental Billionaires (2009)

Mezrich writes true stories built for the screen, and they get there: Bringing Down the House, about MIT students counting cards in Las Vegas, became 21, and The Accidental Billionaires, about the founding of Facebook, became The Social Network. He has published more than twenty books. His method includes reconstructed scenes and dialogue and composite figures, which he acknowledges in author's notes and which reviewers and some subjects have disputed at length.

The commercial extreme of the form Maysh works in, and the useful warning inside it. Mezrich proves that a true story engineered for adaptation will sell; he also shows what it costs, because his books are read as entertainment rather than as reporting and cannot be cited. Maysh's pieces get optioned on the strength of documented detail, which is a harder and more durable trick. Read one Mezrich to see the difference.

— Lisanne
10
The argument against all of it

Janet Malcolm

American · The Journalist and the Murderer (1990), The Silent Woman (1994)

The Journalist and the Murderer opens by declaring that every journalist knows what they do is morally indefensible, and then examines the lawsuit a convicted murderer brought against the writer who had befriended him while reporting his book. Malcolm was herself sued for libel by the psychoanalyst Jeffrey Masson over her book In the Freud Archives, in litigation that ran for a decade before a jury found in her favour. She wrote for The New Yorker for more than forty years and died in 2021.

The book that should be read alongside every title on this page. Malcolm's subject is exactly the transaction Maysh depends on: a reporter earns access from people at the worst moment of their lives, and then publishes something they cannot control and did not expect. She is not saying the work should not be done. She is saying it should not be done while pretending it is a favour. Read it after any true crime story that thrilled you.

— Lisanne

Every book by Janet Malcolm →

Where to start if you loved Jeff Maysh

If you want the closest match, read David Grann.

Killers of the Flower Moon. Murders for oil money, and the case that made the FBI.

If you want the magazine pieces collected, read Patrick Radden Keefe.

Rogues. Twelve improbable people, reported until they make sense.

If you want one short book, one caper, read Michael Finkel.

The Art Thief. Two hundred artworks, taken by a man who simply wanted them.

If you want double lives, read Ben Macintyre.

The Spy and the Traitor. Out of Moscow in the boot of a car.

If you want the argument against it, read Janet Malcolm.

The Journalist and the Murderer. What a reporter actually takes from a subject.

If you want more non-fiction of this kind

My shelf has the rest.

Frequently asked questions about authors like Jeff Maysh

Who should I read if I love Jeff Maysh?

David Grann is the closest — the same forgotten crime dug out of an archive, expanded to book length. Patrick Radden Keefe's Rogues is the single best substitute for a Maysh collection, and Susan Orlean is the warmest version of the same curiosity. Michael Finkel writes the short single-caper book Maysh has not written yet, Ben Macintyre covers the espionage and double-identity material, Skip Hollandsworth the small-town American crime story, and Mark Bowden the newspaper series that became a film. Joseph Mitchell is the ancestor of the whole sensibility. Ben Mezrich is the commercial extreme, and Janet Malcolm is the argument against the trade.

Has Jeff Maysh written a book?

Not a full-length one. He has published shorter works, including pieces about the confidence trickster Victor Lustig, who sold the Eiffel Tower for scrap twice, and about Erwin van Haarlem, the Czechoslovak agent who lived in London for years under a dead child's name. His major work is magazine journalism, in The New Yorker, The Atlantic, the Financial Times, Bloomberg Businessweek, Smithsonian, the BBC and MIT Technology Review. No full-length book has been announced as of September 2026.

What is the McDonald's Monopoly story?

Jerome Jacobson, a former police officer employed to provide security for the printing and distribution of the McDonald's Monopoly game pieces, took the winning pieces and passed them for years to a network of family members, acquaintances and organised crime associates, who claimed the prizes and paid him a share. The scheme ran for more than a decade and involved around twenty million dollars in cash and prizes before the FBI broke it. Maysh published the investigation in the Daily Beast in July 2018, at roughly 8,900 words.

Is there a McDonald's Monopoly film?

The rights were bought within days of publication. 20th Century Fox, with Ben Affleck and Matt Damon's Pearl Street Films, paid a reported one million dollars for the article, outbidding Universal, Netflix and Warner Bros., with Affleck attached to direct and Damon to star as Jacobson. It was reported at the time as one of the largest rights deals ever done for a single magazine article. Film projects frequently stall between option and camera, so check current status before planning a cinema trip.

Where can I read Jeff Maysh's best stories?

His own site lists them with links, which is the fastest route. The ones most often named: the McDonald's Monopoly investigation in the Daily Beast (2018), the story of the German bank robber who signed his ransom notes with a Disney character in The New Yorker (2021), the CIA operation to borrow and photograph a Soviet satellite overnight in MIT Technology Review (2021), the counterfeit Queen of Soul in Smithsonian (2018), and a catfishing story with an unexpectedly happy ending in The Atlantic (2017).

Why are so many of Jeff Maysh's stories being filmed?

Because he reports them as complete stories rather than as pitches, which is the point he makes himself: a finished piece is a piece of intellectual property, and a studio can read it and see the film. He has worked repeatedly with the producer David Klawans, who hunts for forgotten cases in archives that have the right shape. He has since taught a course on the method. He has said dozens of his stories are in development at film and television companies.

Is Jeff Maysh British or American?

Both. He was born in Nassau in the Bahamas in 1982, is British-American, and lives and works in Southern California. He has won five Southern California Journalism Awards, including Best Crime Reporting twice, and his work has appeared in the Atlantic's list of exceptional works of journalism and in Best American Sports Writing. Alongside the journalism he works as an associate creative director in the technology industry.

What should I read first if I have never read him?

The McDonald's Monopoly piece, because it is the one everything else is measured against and it takes about half an hour. Then the Dagobert piece in The New Yorker about the bank robber who taunted police using a cartoon duck, which shows the comic register, and the story of the Czechoslovak spy for the serious one. After that, move to David Grann or Patrick Radden Keefe, because you will want something book length.

Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. Every comparison here is a judgement about method and subject, not an algorithmic match. See more on her personal bookshelf.

From the bookshelf

“The theme of the story is that justice prevails.”

— Jeff Maysh, on the McDonald's Monopoly story, The Hollywood Reporter.

If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.

Browse the full bookshelf Get book recommendations
Start Typing