Reading List

The Best True Crime Writers to Read

In 1959 a farmer, his wife and two of their children are shot in their house in Holcomb, Kansas, and Truman Capote goes there to write about it. In 1980 a former Seattle police officer publishes a book about the killer she had once called a friend. In 2018 a book about the Golden State Killer comes out after its author’s death. True crime writers reconstruct real crimes from the records and the people involved, and ask what they mean. These twelve did it in books, from In Cold Blood to today’s writers on cold cases, con men and the genre itself, each with the book to start with.

By Lisanne Swart · 12 writers · True crime · Updated 10 Nov: new list

Quick answer

Start with In Cold Blood by Truman Capote if you want the classic, or with I’ll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara if you want a modern case. The twelve writers below run from the 1960s to today. For each one there is a short introduction and the book to read first.

The list at a glance

  1. 01Truman Capote In Cold Blood
  2. 02Ann Rule The Stranger Beside Me
  3. 03Janet Malcolm The Journalist and the Murderer
  4. 04Erik Larson The Devil in the White City
  5. 05Maggie Nelson The Red Parts
  6. 06Deborah Blum The Poisoner’s Handbook
  7. 07Robert Kolker Lost Girls
  8. 08Jeff Maysh Handsome Devil
  9. 09Michelle McNamara I’ll Be Gone in the Dark
  10. 10Sarah Weinman The Real Lolita
  11. 11Rachel Monroe Savage Appetites
  12. 12Michael Finkel The Art Thief

Twelve true crime writers, and where to start

01
American · 1960s

Truman Capote

Novelist and journalist

Known for novels and stories such as Breakfast at Tiffany’s, and for In Cold Blood, his account of the 1959 murder of the Clutter family in Kansas, which he called a nonfiction novel.

Where to startStart with In Cold Blood (1966). For readers who want the book modern true crime grew out of.

Every book by Truman Capote →

02
Seattle · Ted Bundy

Ann Rule

True crime writer · former Seattle police officer

A former Seattle police officer who wrote true crime for more than thirty years. Her best-known book is about her friend Ted Bundy.

Where to startStart with The Stranger Beside Me (1980). For readers who want true crime told by someone who knew the killer.

Every book by Ann Rule →

03
The New Yorker · Journalism on trial

Janet Malcolm

Journalist · The New Yorker

Long, sceptical New Yorker reporting on how journalists, biographers and courts turn real people into stories, her own part in it included.

Where to startStart with The Journalist and the Murderer (1990). About the Jeffrey MacDonald case. For readers who want to question true crime itself.

Every book by Janet Malcolm →

04
Chicago 1893 · Narrative history

Erik Larson

Narrative historian

Writes narrative history that reads like a thriller, often by braiding two true stories together, and uses only what the documents show.

Where to startStart with The Devil in the White City (2003). For readers who want a serial killer and a World’s Fair in one book.

Every book by Erik Larson →

05
A family case · Autotheory

Maggie Nelson

Poet and essayist

Known for books that put her own life on the same page as critical theory. Two of them are about the 1969 murder of her aunt, Jane Mixer, in Michigan.

Where to startStart with The Red Parts (2007). About the trial, decades later, of the man charged with the murder. For readers who want a cold case seen from the family’s side of the courtroom.

Every book by Maggie Nelson →

06
Poison · Forensics

Deborah Blum

Science journalist

Turns the history of chemistry, poison and forensic science into narrative nonfiction.

Where to startStart with The Poisoner’s Handbook (2010). For readers who want the birth of forensic toxicology in Jazz Age New York.

Every book by Deborah Blum →

07
Long Island · Families

Robert Kolker

Journalist

Writes narrative nonfiction about families handed something nobody knows how to carry. Lost Girls follows five young women who went missing between 2007 and 2010 and were found along Gilgo Beach on Long Island.

Where to startStart with Lost Girls (2013). For readers who want the victims at the centre, not the killer.

Every book by Robert Kolker →

08
British-American · Con men

Jeff Maysh

Journalist

Writes long true crime stories about people leading double lives, above all his account of the McDonald’s Monopoly fraud.

Where to startStart with Handsome Devil (2016). About the con man Victor Lustig. For readers who want a swindler with style.

Every book by Jeff Maysh →

09
Golden State Killer

Michelle McNamara

True crime writer

Spent years searching for the Golden State Killer. I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, her only book, came out after her death.

Where to startStart with I’ll Be Gone in the Dark (2018). For readers who want obsession and grief in one book.

Every book by Michelle McNamara →

10
Real cases · Literature

Sarah Weinman

Crime writer and editor

Reconstructs real cases, above all the 1948 abduction of Sally Horner and its link to Nabokov’s Lolita.

Where to startStart with The Real Lolita (2018). For readers who want true crime and literary history together.

Every book by Sarah Weinman →

11
Why we read it

Rachel Monroe

Journalist

Wrote Savage Appetites about why so many women are drawn to true crime, told through the stories of four women.

Where to startStart with Savage Appetites (2019). For readers who want to understand their own true crime habit.

Every book by Rachel Monroe →

12
Impostors · Art theft

Michael Finkel

Journalist

Writes long true stories about people who stepped out of ordinary life. His first true crime book, True Story (2005), came out of a 2002 fabrication scandal at The New York Times Magazine.

Where to startStart with The Art Thief (2023). For readers who want a heist told from the thief’s side.

Every book by Michael Finkel →

Not sure where to start?

If you want the classic
→ Start with Truman Capote or Ann Rule.

If you want a cold case
→ Read Michelle McNamara, Robert Kolker or Maggie Nelson.

If you want history that reads like a thriller
→ Read Erik Larson, Deborah Blum or Sarah Weinman.

If you want to think about the genre itself
→ Read Janet Malcolm or Rachel Monroe.

Frequently asked questions about true crime writers

Who are the best true crime writers?

Truman Capote, for In Cold Blood, and Ann Rule, for The Stranger Beside Me, are the best known. More recent names include Michelle McNamara, Robert Kolker, Sarah Weinman and Michael Finkel.

Which true crime book should I read first?

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote if you want the classic, or I’ll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara if you want a modern case.

Is In Cold Blood the first true crime book?

No. Writing about real crimes is much older, but In Cold Blood (1966) is the book most often named as the start of modern true crime. Capote called it a nonfiction novel.

Did Ann Rule know Ted Bundy?

Yes. Ann Rule knew Ted Bundy as a friend before he was identified as a killer, and The Stranger Beside Me (1980) is about that friendship and his crimes.

Are there women true crime writers on this list?

Yes, more than half of them: Ann Rule, Janet Malcolm, Maggie Nelson, Deborah Blum, Michelle McNamara, Sarah Weinman and Rachel Monroe.

Footnotes
  1. The Clutter family were killed in Holcomb, Kansas, on 15 November 1959. In Cold Blood first ran in four parts in The New Yorker in 1965 and was published as a book in 1966.
  2. Michelle McNamara died in April 2016. I’ll Be Gone in the Dark was completed by her researcher Paul Haynes and the journalist Billy Jensen and published in February 2018.

From the bookshelf

“Trust thyself: every heart vibrates to that iron string.”

— Ralph Waldo Emerson, Self-Reliance

More books I keep coming back to are on my personal bookshelf, and every month one of them goes out to the Night Owl Bookclub.

Stay Connected.

I update this list as I read. New picks go to my monthly newsletter first.

Start Typing