Authors Like Dolly Alderton

Reading List

Authors Like Dolly Alderton

Andy Dawson is thirty-five, a stand-up comedian whose gigs are not going well, and Jen has ended it after nearly four years. He starts a list called Reasons Why It's Good I'm Not With Jen, which includes both that she was always on at him about biting his nails and that she pretended to be unsure about wanting children when he thinks she just did not want them with him. He moves into a spare room belonging to Morris, a retired conspiracy theorist who writes fan letters to Julian Assange. Then, forty-four sections in, at the moment Andy is about to walk on stage with the material this has all become, the novel hands the microphone to Jen. Good Material (Fig Tree, November 2023, 336 pages) was a New York Times top ten book of 2024 and was shortlisted for the Wodehouse Prize for comic fiction. Alderton was born in London in 1988, wrote a dating column for The Sunday Times Style, co-created the podcast The High Low, and won a National Book Award in Britain for Everything I Know About Love (2018), which the BBC filmed in 2022. Her stated aim for the novel was the altered state of heartbreak and how mad it can make you feel. The ten below cover the comedy, the heartbreak and the objection.

By Lisanne Swart · 10 authors · Comic fiction and memoir · London · Four books · Updated September 2026

Quick answer

If you love Dolly Alderton, the closest match is Nick Hornby: High Fidelity is the same book thirty years earlier, a man in his thirties making lists about a woman who has left. Nora Ephron wrote the funny break-up novel first and best. Marian Keyes and Meg Mason put real damage under the comedy, Coco Mellors and Bella Mackie are the closest contemporaries, and Sally Rooney is the serious version of the same generation. Rachel Cusk is the argument against: the same subject with the charm removed.

Every book by Dolly Alderton →

Where to start if you loved Dolly Alderton

If you want the closest match, read Nick Hornby.

High Fidelity. The same man, the same lists, thirty years earlier.

If you want the original, read Nora Ephron.

Heartburn. A break-up novel with recipes in it, and a real marriage behind it.

If you want it to actually hurt, read Meg Mason.

Sorrow and Bliss. Just as funny, and it will take the floor out from under you.

If you loved Everything I Know About Love, read Nina Stibbe.

Went to London, Took the Dog. A year back in London at sixty, and very funny.

If you want the argument against her, read Rachel Cusk.

Aftermath. The same subject, with the charm entirely removed.

If you want more novels of this kind

My shelf of the best fiction has the rest.

10 authors like Dolly Alderton

01
The same book, thirty years earlier · Closest match

Nick Hornby

British · Fever Pitch (1992), High Fidelity (1995), About a Boy (1998)

High Fidelity is narrated by Rob Fleming, a record shop owner in his mid-thirties who has just been left by Laura and who organises his misery into top-five lists: worst break-ups, best side one track ones, what went wrong. It became a 2000 film with John Cusack and a later series. Hornby has also written Fever Pitch, about Arsenal and his father, and screenplays including An Education and Brooklyn, both nominated for Academy Awards.

The direct ancestor, and the resemblance is close enough that reviewers named it immediately: a man in his mid-thirties, dumped, cataloguing his own grievances in lists, funny about everything except the thing that matters, surrounded by friends who have moved on to mortgages. What Alderton adds is Jen. Hornby never gives Laura a section of her own, and the difference between the two books is entirely in that decision.

— Lisanne
02
Older than the genre · The break-up comedy

Nora Ephron

American · Heartburn (1983), I Feel Bad About My Neck (2006)

Heartburn is narrated by a cookery writer who discovers, seven months pregnant, that her husband is in love with someone else, and it is very funny and includes recipes. It was barely disguised: Ephron's own marriage to the journalist Carl Bernstein had ended the same way, and the book cost her considerably in the fallout. Mike Nichols filmed it in 1986 with Meryl Streep and Jack Nicholson. She also wrote When Harry Met Sally and directed Sleepless in Seattle, and died in 2012.

The writer who established that a break-up book could be hilarious without being unserious, and that the joke can be the defence mechanism the reader watches you use. Everything Alderton does — the comic inventory of a ruined relationship, the friends, the food, the withheld rage — is in Heartburn, which is a hundred and eighty pages and much sharper than its reputation. Read it in one sitting.

— Lisanne
03
The damage under the jokes

Marian Keyes

Irish · Rachel's Holiday (1997), Grown Ups (2020), Again, Rachel (2022)

Keyes has written more than a dozen novels that are marketed as comic and are routinely about addiction, depression, domestic abuse and bereavement, with the jokes running all the way through. Rachel's Holiday follows a young woman sent to a Dublin treatment centre who is quite sure she does not belong there; Again, Rachel returns to her twenty years later. She has sold tens of millions of copies and has written openly about her own experience of both addiction and depression.

The writer who proved that this register — funny, chatty, apparently light — can carry almost anything, and the one Alderton is most often compared to by British reviewers. Keyes goes considerably darker and has thirty years of practice at hiding structure inside charm. If Good Material made you want the same voice applied to something heavier, start with Rachel's Holiday.

— Lisanne
Every book by Marian Keyes →
04
The funniest sad novel of recent years

Meg Mason

New Zealand-Australian · Sorrow and Bliss (2020)

Sorrow and Bliss is narrated by Martha, forty and newly divorced, looking back at a life shaped by a mental illness that the novel deliberately never names, and by a family who have handled it badly and lovingly in roughly equal measure. It was shortlisted for the Women's Prize for Fiction in 2022 and has been optioned for film. Mason worked as a journalist in London and Sydney before writing it.

The book to read if you want Alderton's comic timing attached to something that genuinely hurts. Both novels are built on a narrator being funny at exactly the moments they cannot afford to be sincere, and both hand you a late reversal that reorganises everything you have read. Mason is the better novelist and the harder read. It is the recommendation on this page I would push hardest.

— Lisanne
05
The same city, the same decade

Coco Mellors

British-American · Cleopatra and Frankenstein (2022), Blue Sisters (2024)

Cleopatra and Frankenstein follows a marriage entered into fast between a young British artist in New York and a much older advertising executive, and then moves outward into everyone around them. Blue Sisters is three sisters returning to the family apartment a year after the fourth has died. Mellors grew up between London and New York and writes drinking, ambition and expensive cities with unusual precision.

The closest contemporary in subject and temperature: young people in a big city, relationships that fail in specific rather than generic ways, and a cast of friends who are as important as the romance. Mellors is more interested in class and money and less inclined to be reassuring. If you liked the ensemble around Andy as much as Andy, read Blue Sisters.

— Lisanne
06
The other London media voice

Bella Mackie

British · How to Kill Your Family (2021), What a Way to Go (2024)

How to Kill Your Family is narrated from prison by Grace Bernard, serving time for the one murder she did not commit, who describes the six she did with total composure. It sold around three quarters of a million copies in Britain and Netflix is adapting it with Anya Taylor-Joy. Mackie was a commissioning editor at The Guardian and deputy editor at Vice News before writing fiction.

The same London, the same generation of media people, the same eye for the exact restaurant and the rich boyfriend's family — and a completely different moral setting. Both writers came out of journalism and both have comic timing built by column deadlines. Mackie is far colder and takes obvious pleasure in her narrator's cruelty. Read her if you want the voice without the vulnerability.

— Lisanne
Every book by Bella Mackie →

Authors like Bella Mackie →

07
The comic memoirist

Nina Stibbe

British · Love, Nina (2013), Reasons to Be Cheerful (2019), Went to London, Took the Dog (2024)

Love, Nina collects the letters Stibbe wrote to her sister while working as a nanny in 1980s north London for a family whose neighbours and dinner guests included Alan Bennett; Nick Hornby adapted it for the BBC. Reasons to Be Cheerful won the Bollinger Everyman Wodehouse Prize. Went to London, Took the Dog is a diary of a year she spent back in London at sixty, lodging with a friend after her marriage ended.

The nearest match for Everything I Know About Love rather than for the novels: a woman writing her actual life in London with impeccable comic timing and no self-pity, and letting the sadness arrive between the jokes. Stibbe is drier and more observational; Alderton is warmer and more confessional. Went to London, Took the Dog is the closest of hers in subject and the funniest thing published that year.

— Lisanne
08
The columnist who became the voice of a cohort

Caitlin Moran

British · How to Be a Woman (2011), How to Build a Girl (2014)

Moran left school at sixteen, was writing for Melody Maker at seventeen and has been a Times columnist for decades. How to Be a Woman mixed memoir and polemic and sold in the millions across dozens of countries; How to Build a Girl is the novel version of the same Wolverhampton childhood. What About Men? (2023) turned the same approach on masculinity and was divisive.

The template for Alderton's career: a newspaper column, a very personal first book that becomes a generational reference point, then fiction. Both write about being a young woman in Britain with a mixture of jokes and real embarrassment, and both have been criticised for a narrow social range. Moran is louder and more polemical. Read How to Be a Woman if Everything I Know About Love was your entry point.

— Lisanne
09
The serious version of the same generation

Sally Rooney

Irish · Conversations with Friends (2017), Normal People (2018), Intermezzo (2024)

Normal People follows Connell and Marianne from a Sligo secondary school through Trinity College Dublin and several years of getting each other wrong; the BBC and Hulu adaptation in 2020 was one of the defining television events of that year. Intermezzo (2024) is about two brothers after their father's death. Rooney writes without quotation marks and is explicit about Marxism as a frame for her novels.

The other novelist people mean when they talk about this generation writing relationships, and the tonal opposite. Rooney removes the jokes, the ensemble comedy and the reassurance, and puts the same material — class, sex, miscommunication, friends who become family — under fluorescent light. Alderton wants you to feel better by the end and Rooney does not care whether you do. Read Normal People.

— Lisanne
Every book by Sally Rooney →

Authors like Sally Rooney →

10
The argument against her

Rachel Cusk

British · Aftermath (2012), Outline (2014), Life of M (2026)

Cusk wrote three memoirs in eleven years and was attacked for all of them; Aftermath, on the end of her marriage, drew hostility she has described as creative death, and one subject of an earlier book sued her. Her answer was the Outline trilogy, in which the narrator barely speaks and other people's lives fill the novel instead. Her latest, Life of M, appeared this autumn.

The same material — a relationship ending, a woman writing it — handled by someone who refuses every technique Alderton relies on. No jokes, no warmth, no ensemble of loyal friends, no sense that the reader is being looked after. Cusk was punished for that and Alderton is rewarded for the opposite, which is worth thinking about. Read fifty pages of Aftermath after Good Material and decide which one is telling you the truth.

— Lisanne
Every book by Rachel Cusk →

Authors like Rachel Cusk →

Frequently asked questions about authors like Dolly Alderton

Who should I read if I love Dolly Alderton?

Nick Hornby is the closest — High Fidelity is recognisably the same novel three decades earlier. Nora Ephron invented the funny break-up book, and Marian Keyes and Meg Mason are the two writers who put genuine damage under the same comic register. Coco Mellors and Bella Mackie are her closest contemporaries, Nina Stibbe the match for the memoir rather than the novels, and Caitlin Moran the template for the career. Sally Rooney is the serious version of the same generation. Rachel Cusk is the argument against everything Alderton does.

Which Dolly Alderton book should I start with?

Good Material (2023) if you want the best written: a break-up narrated by a thirty-five-year-old male comedian, with the final section handed to the woman who left him. Everything I Know About Love (2018) if you want the one that made her name, a memoir of female friendship in her twenties in London, which won a National Book Award in Britain and became a BBC series. Ghosts (2020) is the first novel, about a food writer being ghosted while her father develops dementia. Dear Dolly (2022) collects the advice columns.

Is Dolly Alderton writing a new book?

Nothing has been announced as of September 2026. Her four books appeared in 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2023, so the gap is longer than usual, and she has been working in television alongside the writing. She continues to write her column for The Sunday Times Style, which is the most reliable place to see what she is thinking about.

Why is Good Material written from a man's point of view?

She has said she wanted to write about someone completely different from herself, and to explore how heartbreak presents differently in a man. Andy is invented, but she interviewed a number of men about their own break-ups first, and she was specifically interested in the comedy and the tragedy of a man of that generation feeling obliged to present as functional while everything inside is coming apart. Several of the men she spoke to told her they could not discuss their feelings with male friends they would otherwise die for.

What happens in the last section?

After forty-four sections narrated by Andy, at the moment he is about to perform the stand-up material his break-up has produced, the novel switches to Jen and gives her the final part. Readers routinely report the same experience: having spent three hundred pages entirely on Andy's side, willing her to change her mind, they discover a version of the relationship they had no access to. It is the structural decision that lifts the book above the tradition it comes from, and it is why Hornby is the right comparison and also the insufficient one.

Is Everything I Know About Love a memoir or a novel?

A memoir, and specifically about female friendship in her twenties rather than about romance, despite the title. It covers London house shares, bad dates, drinking, jobs in television and the slow discovery that the friendships were the load-bearing relationships all along. It won the National Book Award in Britain for autobiography of the year and became a BBC One series in 2022, which relocated and reshaped a good deal of it. Read the book first.

What is the criticism of Dolly Alderton?

That the world is narrow and the warmth is a technique. Her books are set among educated, largely white, largely middle-class Londoners with media-adjacent jobs, and the emotional insight has been described as column-shaped — arriving in neat, quotable, well-timed units. The counter is that Good Material is genuinely well built, that the Jen section is a real structural risk, and that being consoling is not the same as being easy. Rachel Cusk is the fastest way to test the objection, because she was destroyed for doing the opposite.

What should I read after Good Material?

Hornby for the ancestor, Meg Mason if you want the same comedy attached to something that actually wounds, and Nora Ephron because she is short and better than both. If it was the London and the friendships you liked rather than the break-up, Nina Stibbe and Coco Mellors. And Sally Rooney if you want to know what the same generation looks like written by someone who is not trying to make you feel better.

Nothing here was suggested by a machine. I picked these ten myself, and the reasons are on the page.

Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. See more on her personal bookshelf.

More from the shelf

Reading list

Best Fiction Books

The novels that stay with you longest.

Reading list

Best Short Story Collections

The collections worth the time.

Author index

Books by Author

Every writer on the shelf.

Author index

Every Author Guide, A–Z

The full alphabetical directory.

From the bookshelf

“The altered state of heartbreak, and how mad that can make you feel.”

— Dolly Alderton, on Good Material.

If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.

Browse the full bookshelf Get book recommendations
Start Typing
Dummy Image

Hi, there.

Home

About

My Bookshelf

Weekly’s

Stay tuned: sign up for the newsletter!