Books About Estrangement

Educated

Tara Westover · 2018

Tara Westover grows up in rural Idaho in a survivalist family that does not believe in schools, doctors, or government. She has no birth certificate. She teaches herself enough to pass the ACT, gets into Brigham Young University, and eventually earns a PhD from Cambridge. The cost is her family. When she begins to question the version of events her family insists on — including the abuse she experienced from her brother — she is faced with a choice that most people cannot imagine: her education, or her belonging. She chooses her education. The family calls it a betrayal.

Educated is one of the most precise accounts ever written of what it actually costs to become yourself when becoming yourself means leaving the people who made you. Westover does not demonise her family — her love for them is present on every page, which is what makes the estrangement so devastating. She understood that the hardest thing about leaving is not the leaving itself but the grief that follows, and that the grief is real even when the leaving was necessary. Read it as the memoir that best captures the specific loneliness of growing beyond the world that formed you.

Read my full review →

The Glass Castle

Jeannette Walls · 2005

Jeannette Walls grows up with parents who are, by any conventional standard, completely unequipped to raise children: her father is a brilliant, charismatic alcoholic who cannot hold a job; her mother is a painter who considers domestic responsibility a form of oppression. The family moves constantly, often without heat or food, and the children largely raise each other. Walls eventually escapes to New York, becomes a journalist, and spends years hiding where she came from. The memoir is about what she owed her parents and what she owed herself.

The Glass Castle sits differently from Educated because Walls never fully estranges herself from her parents — she ends up helping them, resenting it, and loving them anyway, which is the more common and more complicated position. The book captures what estrangement often actually looks like: not a clean break but a long, unresolved negotiation between what you need and what you cannot bring yourself to take away from someone you still love. Read it alongside Educated and the contrast between the two authors’ choices will be the most instructive thing about both books.

A Little Life

Hanya Yanagihara · 2015

Four men meet at a New England college and build lives in New York — as an architect, an actor, a painter, and a lawyer. The novel gradually narrows its focus to Jude St. Francis, the lawyer, whose past is withheld and then slowly, devastatingly revealed. Jude was abandoned as an infant, raised in a monastery, and then subjected to abuse so sustained and so total that the novel becomes, in its second half, almost unbearable to read. He has built a life from which he is, in the deepest sense, estranged — from his own body, from his own past, from the possibility of believing he deserves what his friends give him.

A Little Life belongs on this list because it is the most complete fictional account of what childhood trauma does to an adult’s capacity for belonging. Jude is not estranged from a family — he never had one — but from himself, from the idea that he is someone whose existence is not a burden. Yanagihara wrote a novel that is brutal in its honesty about this and that refuses the consolation of recovery. It will not be the right book for everyone and it does not pretend to be. But for readers who want fiction that takes this subject with full seriousness, there is nothing like it.

Inheritance

Dani Shapiro · 2019

Dani Shapiro takes a DNA test and discovers that her father — the man she adored, who died when she was in her twenties — was not her biological father. She was conceived through a sperm donor without her parents’ full understanding of what they were doing, in a fertility clinic in 1961. The discovery restructures everything she thought she knew about her identity, her family, and the story she had been telling herself about who she was. Both her parents are dead. She cannot ask them.

Inheritance is the book for readers who are interested in estrangement not as a choice but as a discovery — the kind that arrives without warning and makes the past suddenly unreadable. Shapiro writes about the experience of having the ground removed from under a self-narrative with a precision and a lack of self-pity that is rare in this kind of memoir. She does not perform her distress; she examines it. The book is also quietly about what we inherit from people who are not biologically ours, which turns out to be most of what we are.

We Need to Talk About Kevin

Lionel Shriver · 2003

Eva Khatchadourian writes letters to her estranged husband Franklin about their son Kevin, who has committed a school massacre. The novel is structured as Eva’s retrospective account of Kevin’s childhood — her ambivalence about motherhood, her suspicion that something was wrong with Kevin from the beginning, her husband’s refusal to see it, and the event she has spent two years trying to understand. It won the Orange Prize in 2005. The question at its centre — how much of what a child becomes is the parent’s responsibility — has no comfortable answer.

We Need to Talk About Kevin belongs here because it is the most unsparing fictional account of estrangement within a family — not the estrangement that happens when you leave, but the estrangement that happens when you realise you never truly knew the person you lived with. Eva is estranged from Kevin, from Franklin, and eventually from the version of herself that thought she could manage any of it. Shriver does not let Eva — or the reader — off the hook. It is one of the most uncomfortable novels of the past thirty years, which is also why it is one of the most necessary.

The Body Keeps the Score

Bessel van der Kolk · 2014

Van der Kolk’s account of trauma and its physical effects — drawing on decades of clinical work with veterans, abuse survivors, and patients with complex PTSD — argues that trauma is not primarily a psychological event but a physiological one: the body encodes what the mind cannot process, and healing requires working with the body as much as with the mind. It is not a book about estrangement explicitly, but it is the book that most clearly explains why estrangement from family often feels like estrangement from the self.

The Body Keeps the Score belongs on this list as the explanatory framework for everything the memoirs describe. If you have read Educated and wondered why Westover’s relationship with her family is so physically as well as emotionally difficult to escape, this book provides the answer with clinical rigour. Van der Kolk writes for a general audience without oversimplifying, and the result is one of those rare nonfiction books that genuinely changes how you understand your own experience. Read it alongside any of the memoirs on this list and the memoirs become more legible.

Shuggie Bain

Douglas Stuart · 2020

Shuggie Bain grows up in 1980s Glasgow in a council estate, the youngest child of Agnes, a woman of extraordinary beauty and charisma who is also a severe alcoholic. The novel follows Shuggie’s childhood as he watches his mother destroy herself, refuses to leave her, and is slowly destroyed in turn. Stuart wrote it over ten years while working in fashion in New York, drawing on his own childhood. It won the Booker Prize in 2020 and was rejected by thirty-two publishers before it was accepted.

Shuggie Bain is on this list not because it is about leaving — it is about refusing to leave, which is the other form estrangement takes. Shuggie’s love for his mother is absolute and it costs him almost everything, and the novel asks what it means to stay when staying is also a form of self-destruction. The estrangement here is from the life he might have had, from the self that might have been possible, if he had been born into a different house. Stuart writes about poverty and addiction and queer identity in working-class Scotland with a completeness and a warmth that make the tragedy bearable. Just barely.