Author Guide · Contemporary Fiction
Books Written by
In 2018 Christine Pride, a book editor who had held posts at Doubleday, Crown, Hyperion and Simon & Schuster, pitched an idea for a novel to one of her own authors, the journalist and novelist Jo Piazza. It became We Are Not Like Them: a lifelong friendship between a Black woman and a white woman, tested when the white woman’s husband, a Philadelphia police officer, is involved in the shooting of an unarmed Black teenager. Pride had never wanted to write a book before. It came out in October 2021 and was the Good Morning America Book Club pick that month. The two have since written two more novels together, and Pride published her first solo novel in 2025. This guide covers her four key books, in order, and where to begin.
By Lisanne Swart · 4 key books · 2021–2026 · Updated 7 Nov: a note in the margin
ClickTap a spine to jump to that book below.
Quick answer
Christine Pride has written four novels: We Are Not Like Them (2021), You Were Always Mine (2023) and I Never Knew You at All (2026), all three with Jo Piazza, and the solo novel All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025). Start with We Are Not Like Them, the Good Morning America Book Club pick for October 2021; below is what each book is about and how they connect.
Where to Start with Christine Pride
If you want her best-known book
→ We Are Not Like Them (2021) — the novel about two friends and a police shooting in Philadelphia.
If you want a story about motherhood and race
→ You Were Always Mine (2023) — a Black woman raising a white baby left in her care.
If you want a love story
→ All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025) — her solo novel, a love triangle across twenty years.
If you want her newest book
→ I Never Knew You at All (2026) — a marriage, an old flame and a decade-old disappearance.
4 Christine Pride Books, in Order
We Are Not Like Them
Riley, who is Black, and Jen, who is white, have been best friends since kindergarten. Riley is close to becoming one of the first Black women to anchor the television news in Philadelphia; Jen married young and is pregnant. When Jen’s husband, a city police officer, is involved in the shooting of an unarmed Black teenager, the friendship is tested. The chapters alternate between the two women, and the book was the Good Morning America Book Club pick for October 2021.
You Were Always Mine
Cinnamon Haynes, a Black career counsellor at a community college, befriends Daisy, a pregnant nineteen-year-old who is white, on a park bench during her Friday lunch breaks. Daisy then leaves her newborn where Cinnamon will find her, with a note asking her to raise the child. Cinnamon’s husband, the baby’s white grandparents and strangers all react to a Black woman raising a white child, while Daisy’s side of the story arrives in letters addressed “Dear You”.
All the Men I’ve Loved Again
Pride’s first novel without Piazza. Cora Belle, a shy young woman who was one of very few Black students at her private school, falls for Lincoln Ames, an ambitious scholarship student, at Hamlin University; after a tragedy she meets Aaron, a photographer. Nearly twenty years later, approaching forty, she runs into both men again and faces the same choice. Publishers Weekly praised its female friendships and the bond between Cora and her father.
I Never Knew You at All
The newest one, from 2026.Newest!
Simone Hartwell, a Black woman who gave up journalism to raise her son, is married to Alex, heir to Hartwell Inc., an upmarket grocery chain founded by his grandfather. Her college ex-boyfriend Kwame, now a journalist, is investigating the disappearance ten years earlier of a young Black man from The Tate School, the prep school the Hartwell men have attended for generations, and the trail leads to her husband’s family. Atria publishes it on 13 October 2026.
In What Order to Read Christine Pride
None of the four novels continues another, so they can be read in any order. Publication order is still the easiest way in: the two early books with Jo Piazza share a structure, a friendship between a Black woman and a white woman told from both sides, and reading them in sequence shows how the pair handle it.
All the Men I’ve Loved Again stands apart: a single narrator and a love story rather than a crisis. I Never Knew You at All returns to the joint books’ ground, with race, class and a newsroom investigation pressing on a marriage.
A reading path
1. We Are Not Like Them (2021)
2. You Were Always Mine (2023)
3. All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025)
4. I Never Knew You at All (2026)
The years · 2018–2026
Quick facts about Christine Pride
- Known for
- Christine Pride is known for writing novels about friendship, family and race between Black and white characters, most of them with Jo Piazza, after two decades as a book editor.
- 2018
- Pitches the idea for a first novel to Jo Piazza
- Career
- Book editor at Doubleday, Broadway, Crown, Hyperion and Simon & Schuster
- Co-author
- Jo Piazza, journalist and novelist; Pride edited her novel Charlotte Walsh Likes to Win
- First novel
- We Are Not Like Them (2021), a Good Morning America Book Club pick
- Solo debut
- All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025)
- Column
- “Race Matters” for the blog Cup of Jo
- Lives
- New York City
The red mark is 2021: We Are Not Like Them, her first novel with Jo Piazza.
How Christine Pride Writes: Two Women, Two Sides
Pride and Piazza met as editor and author: Pride edited Piazza’s novel Charlotte Walsh Likes to Win at Simon & Schuster. When they wrote We Are Not Like Them, they first worked out the characters together, then built a detailed outline. Piazza drafted most of the early chapters, and the two passed the text back and forth in a shared document with comments, since they have never lived in the same place.
The joint novels are built on paired perspectives. We Are Not Like Them alternates chapters between Riley and Jen; You Were Always Mine sets Cinnamon’s story against Daisy’s letters. The premises are taken from the news, a police shooting or an abandoned baby, and the books spend most of their pages on what follows inside families and friendships.
They research like reporters. For the first novel they interviewed Philadelphia police officers and their spouses, shooting victims and victims’ parents, and went through the archives of local papers, and they chose the city, they said, so that Philadelphia would be “as essential as a character in the book.” Pride has said the premise was loosely inspired by a close childhood friend of hers who is married to a white police officer.
Watch
Christine Pride and Jo Piazza on We Are Not Like Them
Christine Pride and her co-author Jo Piazza talk about their novel We Are Not Like Them at a virtual event hosted by Boswell Book Company in Milwaukee. From the official Boswell Book Company channel.
Frequently asked questions about Christine Pride’s books
How many books has Christine Pride written?
Four novels: three with Jo Piazza, We Are Not Like Them (2021), You Were Always Mine (2023) and I Never Knew You at All (2026), and one on her own, All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025).
What are Christine Pride’s books in order?
We Are Not Like Them (2021), You Were Always Mine (2023), All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025) and I Never Knew You at All (2026).
Where should I start with Christine Pride?
We Are Not Like Them — her first novel with Jo Piazza and still her best known, about two lifelong friends in Philadelphia after a police shooting.
What is Christine Pride’s most famous book?
We Are Not Like Them (2021), which was the Good Morning America Book Club pick for October 2021.
Who is Jo Piazza, and how do she and Christine Pride write together?
Jo Piazza is a journalist, podcast creator and novelist whose books include Charlotte Walsh Likes to Win, which Pride edited at Simon & Schuster. For their first novel they outlined the book together, Piazza drafted most early chapters, and the two then revised in a shared document, since they have never lived in the same place.
Is We Are Not Like Them based on a true story?
Not directly. Pride has said it was loosely inspired by a close childhood friend of hers who is married to a white police officer. The authors interviewed Philadelphia police officers and their spouses, shooting victims and victims’ parents while writing it.
Is We Are Not Like Them being made into a film or series?
In October 2021 the authors told Philadelphia magazine they were in talks to option it for a film or limited series and wanted it shot in Philadelphia. No adaptation had been confirmed in the sources checked for this guide.
Did Christine Pride write a book on her own?
Yes. All the Men I’ve Loved Again (2025) is her solo debut, a love story about Cora Belle, who meets two men in her college years and runs into both again nearly twenty years later.
What is I Never Knew You at All about?
Simone Hartwell, married into a wealthy family that owns a grocery chain, sees her life unsettled when her college ex-boyfriend, now a journalist, investigates a decade-old disappearance at the prep school the Hartwell men attend. It is the third novel by Pride and Piazza, published by Atria on 13 October 2026.
Footnotes
- We Are Not Like Them — Philadelphia magazine, 2021
- GMA Book Club, October 2021 — Good Morning America
- In conversation with Christine Pride and Jo Piazza — Whistles
- You Were Always Mine — Bookreporter
- All the Men I’ve Loved Again — Publishers Weekly
- I Never Knew You at All — Simon & Schuster
Bibliography last verified 9 October 2026. Where sources give different first-publication years, this page uses the year in library catalogues or the publisher’s own record.
This list was not put together by a machine.
The notes are all mine,
and the books are theirs.
Lisanne x
Written by Lisanne Swart, who has curated reading lists and author guides at lisanneswart.com since 2021. Titles, dates and details are checked against the publication record.
See more on her personal bookshelf.
“I never really had a burning desire to write something until this opportunity and idea came together.”
— Christine Pride, interview with Whistles on We Are Not Like Them
If this shelf interested you, the full bookshelf has more: reading lists by theme, author guides, and notes on what is actually worth your time.
Have a look at my shelf Send me the next one